Estonian Minister Talks Cyber Awareness from the Cyber Frontier

Liina Vahtras, Estonia’s Minister of Economy and Industry, speaks at Space Tech Expo Europe. Photo: Laurence Russell for Via Satellite

BREMEN, Germany — Estonia has spent two decades at the cyber frontier. With a generation of experts who have only known vigilance against encroachment by an expansionist power, the nation is eager to export what it has learned.

“One of the first recognized cyber attacks against our country in 2007 started a long campaign of investment and development to battle for the security of our digital infrastructure,” Liina Vahtras, Estonia’s Minister of Economy and Industry, newly appointed this year, told attendees at Space Tech Expo Europe on Tuesday. “Today, we still get a lot of practice from our neighbor.”

After regaining independence in 1991 following the fall of the USSR, the nation was forced to start from scratch.

“We were so poor we couldn’t afford existing systems, which means we needed to build our own, and create our own expertise base,” Vahtras said. “That expertise, hardened by the frontline with Russia, has created a hub ready to export its advantages, with a great remit for regulatory flexibility.”

Estonia is developing a Space Cyber Testing and Training Ground with a consortium of Estonian companies, with funding from the European Space Agency (ESA). The cyber range is intended to provids a platform for simulating cyber threats.

Estonian government and industry both speak of the nation’s ability to support controlled cyber sandboxes where researchers, companies and intelligence agencies can put programs up against everything hackers can throw at them, to model out vulnerabilities, ready for a world teeming with cyber threats.

“In Estonia we have a saying that preparing for something will end up meaning it won’t happen – bring an umbrella, and it’ll end up not raining,” Vahtras said. “The same is true for cybersecurity. Estonia has put great effort into carving out this expertise, and it’s something we want to share with Europe and the rest of the world.”

The Minister said the nation has never been naïve about the threats coming down from Russia, and that before the War in Ukraine, they were used to being dismissed as hysterical about that vigilance.

“It’s more real and normalized to us, but all of Europe faces this threat,” Vahtras told Via Satellite after her conference fireside. “We can hope for a more peaceful world, but we need to be ready for the alternative. We want to be able to put faith into our systems.”

Kristiina Omri, vice president of Special Programs at CybExer, and project manager for an effort to test and validate satellite communications linked to IRIS² is just as clear-eyed about the threat. CybExer is one of the companies building the Space Cyber Testing and Training Ground.

“Defense production, energy, logistics, supply chains and critical infrastructure can all become targets of interference,” Omri told Via Satellite at the conference. “Any technology or service critical for our societies needs to take grey-zone threats seriously. The risk is not only one major incident, but also slow and difficult-to-detect disruption. Ground infrastructure, supply chains and software can be compromised long before the system becomes operational. This is why resilience must be considered from the beginning.”

These threats are often politically embarrassing, but in space cyber attacks can have existential implications, influencing the likelihood of conjunction events.

“Imagine a constellation of hundreds or thousands of satellites suddenly losing the ability to maneuver or coordinate their movements,” Chiara Manfletti, Neuraspace CEO, and a longstanding voice on orbital sustainability, tells Via Satellite at the conference. “In the worst case, a collision could generate debris that threatens the orbital environment for years or decades. A cyber incident does not automatically cause a collision, but it can remove the information and control needed to prevent one. This is why cybersecurity and space safety can no longer be treated as separate disciplines.”